Dubai Investments reported a 23.5% year-on-year drop in third-quarter net profit to AED 391 million, but its broker, FAB Securities, is not changing its view. The firm maintained its Hold rating and AED 4.00 price target, arguing that the headline decline is less worrying than it appears.
The sharp fall is largely due to a comparison with an unusually strong quarter last year. In 3Q25, the company booked large “fair value gains” — accounting gains from revaluing properties and investments rather than from selling more products or collecting more rent. This year, those gains were smaller, which dragged down reported profit even though day-to-day operations remained stable.
Fair value gains are non-cash items. They reflect changes in the estimated worth of assets on the balance sheet, not actual cash coming in. For companies like Dubai Investments, which holds a portfolio of properties and financial stakes, these revaluations can cause quarterly profits to swing around significantly, even when the underlying business is steady.
FAB Securities pointed to steadier progress over the first nine months of the year. Attributable profit rose 2.0% year-on-year to AED 1.03 billion, on total income of AED 3.14 billion. That suggests the company’s core income stream is holding up better than the quarterly figure implies.
The quarter also came in ahead of FAB’s own profit estimate, which the broker said indicates the income mix was more resilient than the headline decline suggests. That helps explain why the target price was left unchanged: analysts often “normalize” earnings by giving less weight to these non-cash valuation moves and focusing on what the business can consistently generate.
What this means for investors
For everyday investors, the key takeaway is that not all profit declines are created equal. When a large chunk of a company’s earnings comes from revaluations, quarterly results become a noisier signal for valuing the business. A drop in fair value gains can make profits look worse than they really are, just as a surge in those gains can flatter the numbers.
That is why FAB Securities is sticking with its AED 4.00 target. The broker’s view appears to hinge more on the nine-month run-rate than on the third-quarter fair value swings. As long as year-to-date profit and total income keep trending upward, the stock may not need a downgrade.
Investors should watch for signs that the underlying income base is strengthening — for example, growth in rental income, sales of properties, or dividends from investments. Those are the drivers that can support the share price over time. In contrast, another quarter dominated by fair value moves may not shift price targets much, because such gains can reverse just as quickly as they appear.
This pattern is not unique to Dubai Investments. Many companies with large property or investment portfolios see their earnings swing on revaluation. For example, Vallourec's profit drop also came with an unchanged outlook, as one-off costs were seen as recoverable. Similarly, Elior's results showed that a deeper loss at a subsidiary didn't derail its own targets.
In the UAE, where Dubai Investments is based, the property market has been strong in recent years, but investors should remember that fair value gains are not cash. They are accounting estimates that can change with market conditions. A company can report high profits on paper while generating less cash, or vice versa.
For those holding Dubai Investments shares, the Hold rating suggests the stock is fairly valued at current levels. The AED 4.00 target implies limited upside from here, but also limited downside risk, assuming the company’s underlying business continues to perform.
As always, it’s wise to look beyond the headline numbers. The third-quarter dip is a reminder that quarterly earnings can be misleading, especially for companies with significant revaluation gains. Focus on the trend over several quarters, and on the quality of earnings — how much comes from real operations versus accounting adjustments.
FAB Securities’ decision to hold its target suggests it sees the recent weakness as a blip, not a trend. But investors should keep an eye on the next few quarters to see if the underlying income momentum continues.


